top of page


19th Century Cocktail
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Woodford Reserve bourbon o ¾ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ¾ ounce Lillet Rouge o ¾ ounce fresh lemon juice Garnish o lemon twist Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with lemon twist. Remarks: This is a surprising cocktail. At first glance the ingredients don't seem like they would play well together, but they do. It is a tart but well-balanced cocktail with a hin


20th Century Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Bombay gin o ½ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ½ ounce Lillet Blanc o ¼ ounce fresh lemon juice Garnish o lemon peel Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with lemon peel. Remarks: This is a cocktail with a noble history. The Crème de Cacao suggests that it would be good after dinner. Something to sip in the dining car as you watch the landscape fly


21st Century Cocktail
PH factor: 8.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o ¼ ounce Pernod Absinthe Supérieure o 2 ounces 1800 Silver tequila o ¾ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ¾ ounce fresh lemon juice Garnish o lemon peel Method: 1. Swirl absinthe to coat the inside of a chilled cocktail glass and discard the excess. 2. Shake remaining cocktail ingredients over ice. 3. Serve up in the prepared glass. 4. Garnish with lemon peel. Remarks: The taste of this cocktail is not easy t


Ace of Diamonds Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Mount Gay XO rum o ½ ounce dark Crème de Cacao o ½ ounce fresh lime juice o 3 dashes Hella Ginger bitters o 1 bar spoon agave syrup Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. Remarks: Maybe we’re spoiled by all the well-balanced cocktails we've tested but we felt the original recipe for this cocktail lacked subtlety. We added bitters and syrup, increased the cacao


Affogato Martini Sundae
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Finlandia vodka o ½ ounce dark Crème de Cacao o ½ ounce Kahlúa o ½ ounce Licor 43 (Cuarenta Y Tres) o 1 large scoop vanilla ice cream Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients except ice cream over ice. 2. Strain into martini glass. 3. Top with ice cream. 4. Serve with a spoon and a smile. Remarks: Never thought of putting ice cream in your martini? Think again. . . .


Agave Kiss Cocktail
PH factor: 10 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces 1800 Silver tequila o ½ ounce Chambord o 1 ounce light Crème de Cacao o 1 ounce cream Garnish o sliced strawberry Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Strain into an ice-filled Old Fashioned glass. 3. Garnish with sliced strawberries. Remarks: We debated the rating of this creamy confection. Then we decided if your first reaction is, “Wow, that’s a ten.” Then perhaps it should rate a


Alexander Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces Bombay Sapphire gin o 1 ounce dark Crème de Cacao o 2 ounces cream Garnish o grated nutmeg Method: 1. Shake over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with nutmeg. Remarks: In 1915 this cocktail called for equal parts of the ingredients. After testing we found that we liked it better with less Crème de Cacao. . . .


Alfonso Champagne Cocktail
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 sugar cube o 1-2 dashes Angostura bitters o 1 ounce light Crème de Cacao o champagne Garnish o lemon twist Method: 1. Place bitters-soaked sugar cube in a champagne flute. 2. Add Crème de Cacao. 3. Top with champagne. 4. Garnish with a lemon twist. Remarks: This is a traditional Champagne Cocktail where Crème de Cacao takes the place of cognac. That’s where the similarity ends. . . .


Barbary Coast
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ounce Johnnie Walker Red Label scotch o ½ ounce Bombay Sapphire gin o ¾ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ¾ ounce cream Garnish o grated nutmeg Method: 1. Shake vigorously over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with nutmeg. Remarks: It's a creamy cocktail that may not seem like the type of thing denizens of the Barbary Coast would be sipping. But perhaps we’re just being prejudiced. . . .


Bare-Naked Lady Martini
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ounce Finlandia vodka o 1 ½ ounces Godiva White Chocolate liqueur o ½ ounce light Crème de Cacao o 2 ounces cream Garnish o ground cinnamon o cinnamon stick Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Strain into a martini glass. 3. Garnish with a cinnamon stick and ground cinnamon. Remarks: In honor of the true heroism of Lady Godiva. Often overlooked or made light of in spite of the enormity of her


Brandy Alexander Cocktail
PH factor: 8.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Hennessy VS cognac o 1 ounce dark Crème de Cacao o 1 ounce cream Garnish o grated nutmeg Method: 1. Shake over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with nutmeg. Remarks: This is a slightly later version of the 1915 Alexander Cocktail, a classic in its own right. It's not a mistake. We often use Hennessy VS cognac in place of brandy if we think it appropriate. . . .


Brown Cow Cocktail
PH factor: 8.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces dark Crème de Cacao o 4 ounces milk Method: 1. Stir cocktail ingredients over ice in a mixing glass 2. Strain into an ice-filled collins glass. Remarks: Simple enough. Perhaps a bit too simple. If you're worried that you've outgrown your taste for chocolate milk, this drink might ease your angst. In more ways than one. . . .


Chocolate and Orange Martini
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces Finlandia vodka o 1 ounce light Crème de Cacao o 1 splash Cointreau o ½ ounce fresh lemon juice Garnish o 1 Hershey’s Kiss Method: 1. Moisten the rim of a martini glass and invert it into a shallow dish of cocoa powder to coat the rim of the glass. 2. Lightly press a chocolate kiss onto the bottom of the g lass. 3. Shake remaining cocktail ingredients over ice. 4. Serve up in the prepared glass


Commodore #2
PH factor: 8.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces Old Forester bourbon o ¾ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ¼ ounce grenadine o ½ ounce fresh lemon juice o 1 dash Angostura bitters or to taste Garnish o lemon twist Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Strain into an ice-filled Old Fashioned glass. 3. Garnish with lemon twist. Remarks: The Old Waldorf-Astoria Bar Book called for Bacardi rum and followed a path that led to a sweeter cockta


Covet Thy Neighbor’s Cocktail
PH factor: 10 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ounce Woodford Reserve bourbon o ½ ounce Pedro Domencq Fundador brandy o ½ ounce dark Crème de Cacao o ½ ounce Godiva Chocolate Liqueur Garnish o 2 Tillen Farms BaDa Bing cherries Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients over ice. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with cherries. Remarks: This is the perfect cocktail for chocolate lovers, dessert lovers, cocktail lovers, and any other kind of lovers


Cupid’s Arrow Cocktail
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Finlandia vodka o 1 ounce light Crème de Cacao o ½ ounce Licor 43, Cuarenta Y Tres o ¼ ounce strawberry jam o 2 ounces Lindemans Strawberry Lambic Method: 1. Drizzle chocolate syrup on the inside of a large cocktail glass. 2. Shake cocktail ingredients except lambic over ice. 3. Strain into the prepared glass. 4. Top with lambic. Remarks: You will taste the chocolate in this one. We used Ghirarde


Federation Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o ¼ ounce Pernod Absinthe Supérieure o 2 ounces 1800 Añejo tequila o ½ ounce light Crème de Cacao o 1 dash Angostura bitters or to taste Garnish o orange twist Method: 1. Swirl absinthe in chilled cocktail glass and discard the excess. 2. Stir remaining cocktail ingredients over ice in a mixing glass. 3. Strain into the prepared glass. 4. Garnish with orange twist. Remarks: We were a little divided on


Flatiron Cocktail
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Johnnie Walker Black Label scotch o ¼ ounce Ilegal mezcal o ¾ ounce Lillet Blanc o ½ ounce Amontillado sherry o ¼ ounce light Crème de Cacao Garnish o grapefruit peel Method: 1. Stir cocktail ingredients over ice in a mixing glass. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with grapefruit peel. Remarks: This is a strong and attractive cocktail. The five spirits needed to make it will have a


Fogerty Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces Heaven’s Door Straight Rye whiskey o ½ ounce Campari o ¼ ounce dark Crème de Cacao o 1 dash Hella Orange bitters or to taste Garnish o orange twist Method: 1. Stir cocktail ingredients over ice in a mixing glass. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with an orange twist. Remarks: Usually, a cocktail with Campari is all about Campari. But this is not your usual Campari cocktail. . .


Fox River Cocktail
PH factor: 8.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces Woodford Reserve bourbon o ¼ ounce dark Crème de Cacao o 2 dashes Angostura bitters Garnish o orange peel Method: 1. Stir cocktail ingredients over ice in a mixing glass. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with an orange peel. Remarks: An interesting pairing that is made complete, in our opinion, by the bitters. . . .


Frozen Brandy Alexander
PH factor: 9.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ½ ounces Hennessy VS cognac o ¾ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ½ cup vanilla ice cream Garnish o grated nutmeg Method: 1. Add a quarter cup of ice to the cocktail ingredients and blend to a milkshake-like consistency. 2. Serve up in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with grated nutmeg. Remarks: Makes you wonder why you'd ever have a vanilla shake any other way. We used Hennessy VS cognac. Feel free to follow our ex


Golden Cadillac Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o ¾ ounce Galliano o ¾ ounce light Crème de Cacao o ¾ ounce cream Garnish o ground cinnamon Method: 1. Shake over ice. 2. Strain into in a cocktail glass. 3. Garnish with ground cinnamon. Remarks: In a word, pleasurable. Not too much chocolate. Not too much anise. Not too creamy. Just pleasurable. . . .


Licorice Stick Cocktail
PH factor: 9.0 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 2 ounces Finlandia vodka o 1 ounce Sambuca Romano o ½ ounce light Crème de Cacao Garnish o 1 licorice stick Method: 1. Stir cocktail ingredients over ice to chill in a mixing glass. 2. Strain into a martini glass. 3. Garnish with licorice stick. Remarks: Stir well. It should be well chilled and a little dilution is not a bad thing here. By the time you get to enjoying the garnish, you will understand.


Not Too Late, Tonic
PH factor: 8.5 Recipe Ingredients: Cocktail o 1 ounce Bombay gin o ¼ ounce dark Crème de Cacao o ¾ ounce decaf cold-brew coffee o ½ ounce Cardamom Allspice Cordial (see: Syrups etc.) o Fever-Tree Premium Tonic Water Garnish o mint sprig Method: 1. Shake cocktail ingredients except tonic over ice. 2. Strain into an ice-filled collins glass. 3. Top with tonic water. 4. Garnish with mint sprig. Remarks: When we first looked at this we said, “Really?"
bottom of page
